The university response is basically terrible. It fails in some fairly standard ways, including the 'focus only on tightly controlled evidence'.
I'm baffled that they didn't see some of these failures coming. I just, the whole thing is imploding so vigorously that my jaw keeps dropping.
The committee's refusal to even clarify how many years their original statement meant is staggering. I'm starting to wonder if the committee doesn't even know what they meant!
no subject
Date: 2014-07-21 07:39 pm (UTC)I'm baffled that they didn't see some of these failures coming. I just, the whole thing is imploding so vigorously that my jaw keeps dropping.
The committee's refusal to even clarify how many years their original statement meant is staggering. I'm starting to wonder if the committee doesn't even know what they meant!